Skip to main content

9" Pumpkin Pie

$12.99


Item # 1567

Pre-order

We are happy to take your order.

Troyer's Amish Baked Pies will be available for Thanksgiving preorder through November 21, 2026. Pies can be picked up in our shop on Tuesday, November 24 after 3:00PM or Wednesday, November 25 from 9:00A - 5:00PM.

Questions? Give us a call at 330-836-2727.




Recently Viewed

Chocolate Chunk Brownies

Chocolate Chunk Brownies


Pre-order   
$8.99

9" Blueberry Pie

9" Blueberry Pie


Pre-order   
$14.99

9" Coconut Creme Pie

9" Coconut Creme Pie


Pre-order   
$12.99

9" Elderberry Pie

9" Elderberry Pie


Pre-order   
$14.99