Skip to main content

Thanksgiving Pie Preorder

Order Amish baked pies and treats for your holiday celebrations. Please put November 24 after 3PM or November 25 as your pick-up date in the comment section. Those are the only two dates we will have pies.

9" Apple Pie

9" Apple Pie


Pre-order   
$12.99

9" Blackberry Pie

9" Blackberry Pie


Pre-order   
$14.99

9" Blueberry Pie

9" Blueberry Pie


Pre-order   
$14.99

9" Cherry Pie

9" Cherry Pie


Pre-order   
$14.99

9" Chocolate Cream Pie

9" Chocolate Cream Pie


Pre-order   
$12.99

9" Coconut Creme Pie

9" Coconut Creme Pie


Pre-order   
$12.99

9" Elderberry Pie

9" Elderberry Pie


Pre-order   
$14.99

9" Peach Pie

9" Peach Pie


Pre-order   
$12.99

9" Pecan Pie

9" Pecan Pie


Pre-order   
$17.49

9" Pumpkin Pie

9" Pumpkin Pie


Pre-order   
$12.99

9" Red Raspberry Pie

9" Red Raspberry Pie


Pre-order   
$14.99

9" Rhubarb Pie

9" Rhubarb Pie


Pre-order   
$12.99

9" Triple Berry Pie

9" Triple Berry Pie


Pre-order   
$14.99

Chocolate Chunk Brownies

Chocolate Chunk Brownies


Pre-order   
$8.99

Cinnamon Rolls

Cinnamon Rolls


Pre-order   
$7.99

Pumpkin Bars

Pumpkin Bars


Pre-order   
$8.99

Not seeing what you're looking for?   Some items are categorized generically and aren't searchable by their name. Feel free to give us a call at (330) 836-2727 or send us an email to orders@grafgrowers.com to confirm pricing & availabilities! We deliver locally, too!